|
ファンの声を、Guardian紙のコメント欄から拾ってみました。
UTD are desperate for a bit of players with creativity (kagawa)
.... while chelsea for some offensive ideas from their manager and coaches 香川真司のような創造性あるプレーヤーがいるだろ！ The game was crying out loud for a creative midfielder,
someone like Kagawa and he's sitting on the bench laying eggs. This was the season when Kagawa is suppose to own our
midfield, two seasons ago he was Bundesliga player of the year, playing in a team that would rip apart United in their current form, Kagawa should be questioning Moyes and asking about his place in the first XI, 創造性あるプレーヤーが必要なときに、香川真司はベンチで卵抱いているし。。。 It's a travesty that Kagawa and Mata had to sit through that
utter shite. Two immensely gifted and talented players made watch the shit served up tonight. 香川真司とマタのような才能あるプレーヤーが共にベンチでしょーもない試合見さされてた。
A team that benches a player like Kagawa simply doesn't
deserve to win the premier league. Why bring on the 39-year- old Ryan Giggs when you have Shinji Kagawa? Might I add that Kagawa was Bundesliga player of the year
before turning into a bench warmer for Man Utd. He'd be a great transfer target for Arsenal if you ask me. 香川真司みたいなのをベンチにおいてたら勝てないわな。 彼はManUのベンチウォーマーになる前は、ブンデスの年間最優秀選手だった。アーセナルがほしがるな。
Mata and Kagawa both on the bench...
Thats football criminal right there
マタと香川真司がベンチ？ それは犯罪だな。
United really struggled to do anything creative in the final
third and I was shouting at my screen when I saw that Giggs was coming on and not Kagawa. 香川真司じゃなくてギグズが出てきたときは叫んじゃったわ。
|
香川真司 記事へのコメント
[ リスト | 詳細 ]
コメント（2）
|
昨日UPした記事のコメントからです。
Would Kagawa be the answer to Rooney’s departure?
Let us know what you think in the comments below.
Francis Red Devil
I am a numbers guy and figures are there to say, what SAF and
all of us fans saw in the young samurai. Kagawa is world class but his niche of play is just what it is. J KLOPP will tell you that it is quite rare to have a CAM who is good is close quarters, brilliant in assists and an eye for goal. Frankly i have not seen any player like this yet. Neutral99
If Rooney is a legend for United it’s because of his abilities as a
striker, not as a playmaker in behind the striker. He is not on Kagawa’s level in terms of technical ability and creativity to open opposition up. Everyone keeps using fitness as an excuse for Kagawa’s poor
season but I don’t buy that, he was “only” out for 2 months and also toward the end of the season he wasn’t being bundled off the ball like he was at the start of the campaign. So suggestions that isn’t strong enough for the EPL aren’t justified in my eyes either, just look at Cazorla, Silva, etc. I feel his lack of impact has been down to his team mates not
quite understanding his style of play. At the start of the season you would see him demanding the ball with a few players around him and his team mates choosing other options that lead to nothing. In the second half of the season he scored, assisted or created chances in these types of tight positions numerous time. One that springs to mind for me is assist for Rooney against
Southmpton, for me, that was a turning point in how his team mates saw him. Players like Carrick, Scholes and Rooney were always seeking him out to play a pass to and I think the whole team gradually understood how he plays his football to the point where I don’t quite think he will be perfect come the start of next season but perhaps from after Christmas and beyond. I think Moyes will like him but if Rooney stays I feel he, like Sir
Alex, will use Rooney behind the striker because of the player Rooney was/is as a striker. Perhaps he will come to the realisation that Rooney in CAM is slow, clumsy and wasteful compared to Kagawa and change his tactics but if Rooney stays it’s going to be the same frustrating line up that scraped so many wins last season whilst Kagawa will be stuck out on the left wing. John Robart
i believe kagawa has the potential to be one of united’s best
players. but only if united play him in the right position. with him being 24, the next 2-3 years will be critical in his development. maybe united could play rooney as a second striker? (or rotate him and kagawa but this way would allow both players regular playing time) a 4132 formation: evra, vidic ferdinand, rafael, carrick as CDM (allowing carrick to sweep from side to side behind the attacking midfielders and play balls to get the attack started)zaha, kagawa as CAM, valencia (potentially thiago?) as RAM, rooney and rvp as dual strikers. this way would allow more attacking from rafael and evra too. |
|
こちら の記事へのコメントから拾ってみました。
Comments
12.Constructive Critic 20th June 2013 - 2:33 Oh my god... What a spectacle. Kagawa ran the show, what a
performance. I feel absolutely gutted for Japan, totally deserved all 3 points, not
only on the balance of play, not only on the style of football but in the atmosphere of the stadium and winning over the neutral fans it was electric. Hitting the post on 3 occasions and the harshest penalty ever seen. Most unlucky team ever. What a game. 19.ZDe123 20th June 2013 - 2:51
Ref had bad game. No way did Italy deserve to win that. And Japan
showed their true colours because in the first game they had to make a halfway-round the world flight from Japan to Brazil (how many hours?) because of a WCQ game and were jetlagged. Kagawa can cross I didn't know he could hit a long ball like Scholes! Can't wait to see him try that playmaker role next year at United! 23.CarrickSneijder 20th June 2013 - 3:07
Wow, what a game of football, end to end stuff, some amazing
individual displays from Kagawa, Honda, and Nagamoto. Such a shame Japan are going to go home early. 33.Patrick 20th June 2013 - 4:55
Italy were in no way the better team tonight, Japan severely
outplayed them. Although, they did show their professionalism by still carving out the result. Hopefully the next world cup will be filled with enthralling games like this one, and we can all just forget about the mediocre display in South Africa. 52.geoffn54 20th June 2013 - 8:12
Great game. Japan looked really good on the ball and suspect without
it. The Italians were outplayed for long periods but showed typical resilience. And the refereeing was poor once again: this time 2 penalties given that weren't. Puzzling why Kagawa can't get into the United team. Honda and him
were a different class. Maybe it's the Arshevin (world class for his country) treatment at Arsenal. 54.DavidD 20th June 2013 - 8:21
I thought Japan were quite unlucky at times. Buffon could have been
off after half an hour, the penalty given against Japan can be argued and then a goal disallowed. But, an absolutely superb game of football and Japan could easily give
some of the top teams a scare next year. Hopefully Kagawa plays plenty of games under Moyes. Brilliant player.
82.BaggiosPonytail 20th June 2013 - 9:46
Yeah that is it in a nutshell. Italy play poorly and win. We would have
been beaten. Kagawa looked very sharp and linked up well with Honda. How he
missed that chance at the end i'll never know. Easier to score! 104.Steve 20th June 2013 - 10:39
Italy nicked the match. Japan were focused, brave skillful and unlucky.
Great match to watch. Kagawa, Honda and all were excellent, quick one and two touch football, incisive passing, they were up for it. Italy hung on in and stole the points, as they may eventually admit. Japan found honour in defeat. Enjoying the Confederation cup this time around. If Italy play that badly against Spain it’s over 111.OriginalJonBlaze 20th June 2013 - 10:49
I am soooo tired today, but that game was totally worth it! Japan
were absolutely class and the Azzurri were absolutely ruthless. Both sides should take a bow! I salute you all. ★ruthless /rúːθləs/ 無慈悲な，無情な，冷酷な.
121.Hicko 20th June 2013 - 11:05
@114 - Totally agree. Although Spain are a collection of fantastic
footballers, their slow build up play can be a bit tedious to watch. Given the choice of watching Spain or the Japan that turned up last night, it would be Japan every time. Italy couldn't get the ball off them and were totally out-footballed. Super skill, fast incisive passing and everyone able to play. Kagawa was outstanding 132.Jammyred 20th June 2013 - 11:27
This was probably the best game I've ever seen in my life! Thank you
Japan. 133.saranta 20th June 2013 - 11:28
Wow, what a howler by Kagawa. Anyway, great game!
★howler /h́aʊlɚ(米国英語)/ ほえる獣.
204.Johno 20th June 2013 - 17:26
I fell asleep and didn't experience this thrilling feast of football ?
First 30 minutes Italy were playing hoofball and Japan running around like headless chickens. 207.grahame 20th June 2013 - 18:15
One of the best games of football I have seen in a long time. England,
take note and see what can be achieved at playing with a higher tempo and crisp pass and move football. 香川真司のシュート よく撮れてますね。
©ロイター
|
|
Refcafe から。
写しただけで恐縮です・・。
Quote:
You are being harsh on the guy. Competing with Rooney for a position is not easy
especially considering his injury.
I get where you are coming from but it is more about an unfortunate situation rather than his own performance being bad. I would rate his individual
performance this season excellent, although the results he has achieved has
been very average.(Due to injuries and competing with Rooney for his position.)
Just look at everybody here saying they are not scared of Rooney leaving because we have Kagawa. He got through his injury very well and he showed us he can
replace Rooney if he goes or when he is injured/moves position.
|
|
These were my PL expectations of Kagawa before the 12/13 season.
Expectations 香川真司への期待
1. Start at least half the PL games(19).
2. Score/assist somewhere between 10 and 15 times. 3. Play at least 50% of the time behind the striker. 4. Stand out as one of our most entertaining and technical players. 5. Become integrated to such an extent that he's almost sure to be a first XI regular when the 13/14 season starts.
Did he live up to my expectations? 香川真司は期待に応えたか？
1. No, he only started 17 games.
2. Yes, he got 6 goals and 4 assists, barely pushing him over
the minimum demand of 10 goals/assists.
3. No, he only played around 1/3 of the time behind the striker.
4. Yes, most definitely. In my opinion, only RVP can challenge
Kagawa in this aspect.
5. Yes, I think he's considered a first XI regular by now.
He's not as "safe" as Carrick, RVP or DDG, but he's still a player
who's expected to start most games
Summary Kagawa didn't live up to all my expectations, but his injury is largely to blame for that. Had he not been injured, then I'm sure that he
would have started more than half the PL games. The injury also
slowed down his process of adjusting to the league, making his way
back into the team unnecessarily hard. At least 30% of the season
got ruined because of this injury, because Fergie had to ease
Kagawa into the squad again. At this point, he also had to play
on the wing, seeing as Rooney was back and well-established
behind the striker.
In short: the injury "ruined" Kagawa's season. If we take the injury and him playing out of position into account, Kagawa actually
did better than expected. He did have a pretty good goals/assist
ratio. He did succeed at playing sexy football. He did establish
himself as our best passer of the ball(now that Scholes has retired).
He also had the best stamina scores since David Beckham.
These are all remarkable first-season achievements for a young
player who has struggled with injuries and has been played out of
position. Anyone who says otherwise have overly high expectations.
I'm looking forward to next season 関係ないですが・・、宇宙戦艦ヤマト2199 のエンディング best of my love
|
